Question four on the city's feedback form for the Flatiron plazas asks for a preferred alternative "for the block of Broadway between 23rd Street and 22nd Street." It offers three answers: "Alternative 1: Plaza Block," "Alternative 2: Shared Street," and "None of these."
That one question is most of what residents can still shape. Over 2026 the City Council approved the concession that lets the Flatiron NoMad Partnership manage the plazas, the Department of Transportation marked the project fully funded, and construction was put on the calendar. The open item is a single block. The argument over it centers on loading, sanitation and building access.
The Council Vote in August
On August 13, 2026, the New York City Council approved application C 260123 MCM, the Flatiron NoMad Major Concessions. It was approved in committee and by the full Council on the same day, one day after the Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises passed it.
The approval clears the way for DOT to enter a new concession agreement with the Partnership. Under DOT's application, the Flatiron NoMad Partnership's concession area grows from 38,500 square feet to a proposed 162,345 square feet, a bit more than four times its current size. In its May 14 recommendation, Manhattan Borough President Brad Hoylman-Sigal's office described the area as 12 blocks, from 19th to 31st Streets along Broadway and parts of Fifth Avenue, which the Partnership could manage under one agreement "including public amenities and revenue-generating activities that fund ongoing maintenance of the space."
DOT's presentation to Community Board 5 states the limit on that commercial use: concession seating may take up no more than 50 percent of a pedestrian plaza's area.
The Borough President recommended approval with conditions, and those conditions show what the next phase is supposed to deliver. They ask for:
- Sustainability terms in the concession agreement, including limits on single-use items and support for composting and recycling
- Dedicated space for nonprofit programming in how sub-concessions and events are permitted, with accessibility and inclusivity given priority when conflicts come up
- A study of public restrooms, water fountains, green infrastructure and utility hookups for vendors in the upcoming Broadway Vision capital work
The third condition matters most for the plazas as built. Restrooms, fountains and vendor power all need pipes and conduit, so they belong in a full street rebuild.
Most of the Budget Goes Underground
The city has been converting Broadway around the Flatiron Building since 2008, when it installed the first pedestrian plazas there, a year before cars were removed from parts of Times Square. Most of what exists today is paint, planters and plastic bollards. The capital project replaces that with concrete, in-ground plantings and trees, new lighting and new seating.
Streetsblog NYC reported in February that the Department of Design and Construction puts the cost at $156 million for Broadway from 21st to 27th Streets. About $89 million is for the street work. The other $67 million is for sewer and water mains. That puts more than 40 percent of the budget below ground. It also explains why the timeline is long, and why things like restrooms can be considered at all.
The same report lists five new raised blocks, protected bike lanes, a new roadway alignment, security bollards, curb extensions, raised crosswalks, landscaping and concession kiosks.
Here is the 2026 sequence:
- February 18: DOT presents Broadway Vision to Community Board 5. Streetsblog reports the comment that the goal is a pedestrian and cyclist priority corridor "from Union Square all the way up through Columbus Circle."
- May 14: The Borough President recommends conditional approval of the concession.
- August 13: City Council approves it.
- September 24: CB5's Transportation Committee hears a DOT design update.
- October 8: The capital reconstruction is on CB5's full board agenda.
- October 14 and 15: DOT holds public workshops on the South Plaza.
- 2028: Construction begins, according to DOT's October deck, which also marks the plazas fully funded.
- 2031: DDC's estimated completion, as reported by Streetsblog in February.
Uptown offers a comparison. Streetsblog's February piece reported that the first concrete rebuild of Broadway since Times Square, at 39th and 40th Streets, was set to start in September 2026 and take about two years for two blocks. Flatiron's six blocks are a much larger job.
The Block Between 22nd and 23rd
The workshops took place on the block in question. The Flatiron NoMad Partnership set them for noon to 2 p.m. on the South Plaza, on Broadway between 22nd and 23rd Streets, with no registration required.
The October workshop deck shows the two options. Both alternative sheets include 68 Citi Bike docks and areas marked for seating, dining and flexible events. The Shared Street sheet adds a double-size kiosk. The difference between them is whether vehicles can still use that block of Broadway at all.
In September, CB5's Transportation Committee reached its position. According to a Sundays summary of the meeting, the committee supported pedestrianizing Broadway between 23rd and 22nd Streets on condition that loading needs are met and the Department of Sanitation is part of the final plan. Public comment was "less on the idea of change than on how the block would function afterward," and speakers raised building access. The same summary says the committee also asked for sanitation planning, safety data, public bathrooms and a continuous bike connection through the area.
The two alternatives look alike on paper: the same dock count and similar seating and event space. What separates them is daily operations. Where does a moving truck park? Where do trash bags get picked up? How does a bike rider get from 22nd to 23rd without dismounting? Those details will decide how this block works in 2031.
The Form Is Still Open
The DOT feedback form has four feedback questions. They cover landscaping, lighting and plaza features; circulation for pedestrians, cyclists, buses and vehicles; the 22nd to 23rd Street choice; and any other comments. It also asks for a home ZIP code and offers email updates. Full project materials are on the DOT project page. Questions go to [email protected].
The circulation question also covers buses. DOT's circulation maps cover express, local and tour bus stops around Madison Square Park, and the proposed layout redraws how those stops sit along Fifth Avenue and Broadway. Anyone who catches a bus at the park can check those maps before commenting.
What the Plazas Hold Until 2028
Until construction starts, the plazas stay as they are. The Partnership's plaza FAQ lists moveable tables and chairs, shade umbrellas, seasonal edge planters, and one food and beverage kiosk on each of its two Flatiron plazas.
Across Fifth Avenue, Madison Square Park has its own calendar for the rest of the year:
- Through December 6: Roberto Lugo's "Alfarero del Barrio (Village Potter)" is in its final weeks. It includes a 20-foot urn, a 15-foot fire hydrant, tire planters and domino tables visitors can play at.
- December 3: The Madison Square Park Conservancy's free Holiday Festival runs from noon to 5:30 p.m. at the South Gravel. Music and treats begin at 4:30 p.m. at the Northern Reflecting Pool, and the tree is lit at 5 p.m.
- December 16: Executive Director Holly Leicht leads a free park history tour from noon to 1 p.m., meeting at the northwest entrance at Fifth Avenue and 26th Street.
The building that gives the plazas their name is also changing. New York YIMBY reported on November 2 that the 36-condominium conversion at 175 Fifth Avenue has started receiving residents. Remaining residences are expected by year-end and the full amenity package in early 2027. Bar Pisellino Flatiron Building, from Rita Sodi and Jody Williams, is slated for the restored ground floor facing the Broadway plaza in 2027.
That means the Flatiron Building will be a residential address facing the plaza when the 2028 construction start arrives. For its residents, how the block between 22nd and 23rd handles deliveries and trash is a practical matter that affects them directly.
At Josue Gonzalez Realty, we follow public projects like the Broadway rebuild because street access, loading rules and construction schedules affect how a building works for the people who live there. If you own near the plazas and want to know how a multi-year project nearby could factor into your home's value, start with our instant home valuation and we'll take it from there.